Archaeology of Tara and the M3

Madam - I have never known the archaeological profession to be as united as it is at present over the desecration at Tara. The only archaeologists I have heard speaking in favour of the road are the NRA's own in-house ones and I suspect that even they may hold different opinions in private. All archaeologists are aware that rescue archaeology in advance of development is not best practice.

Conor Newman (October 9th.) is correct to call the current mess wilful bad planning, but I would suggest that it is not entirely the fault of the NRA. Surely An Bord Pleanála bears some responsibility for this fiasco? Its weak-kneed, unquestioning acceptance of whatever road plans are put before it shows that it is simply the Government's rubber-stamping department, completely lacking the independence it is supposed to have.

- Yours, etc.

Brian Hodkinson,
MIAI.,
Annaholty,
Birdhill,
Co. Tipperary.

© The Irish Times, 12th. October 2004.