The pencil, the snail and the Taoiseach

Dear sir - Our Taoiseach seems to think little of the humble pencil or indeed of people admitting that they are wrong and changing their minds.

Last week in the Dáil he made the astounding statement that our "silly old system is outdated" that we should "correct the software and move forward" and that we are a "laughing stock with our silly old pencils".

Last year he also referred to pencils as the Irish Times said: 'In what could only be taken as a reference to the Kildare bypass - where a rare snail's habitat was discovered, and the proposed M3 in Co. Meath which passes through an area of significant archaeology - Mr. Ahern said: "in other countries they just get on with things. If you take a pencil and account for things like snails and archaeology you will never do anything". (Tim O'Brien, Irish Times, September 30 2005).

If someone did use a pencil for the route of the M3 it must have been late at night on the back of an envelope in a pub, the pencil then slipped and the route to be most avoided was chosen by mistake. There is no other explanation for such an idiotic route - or is there?

Our Taoiseach also faulted the opposition for changing their minds on the issue of electronic voting, unlike him they had the sense to listen to the experts.

Finally, in other countries they do not "just get on with things" - in Gran Canaria when the route of a major highway unearthed a Guanche graveyard containing 1,000 skulls the Spanish government moved the road.

This government should put its hands up and admit that a monumental planning mistake has been made or put their trust in those great voting machines and hold an e-referendum on the round-the-bend route of the M3.

Dr. Muireann Ní Bhrolcháin

© The Meath Chronicle, 4th. November 2006.